Having been sick for a few days, I have
spent a lot more time watching movies than I usually do – via the
movie-streaming option that the Xbox suddenly acquired for no reason.
I thought the Tintin movie was true to
the spirit of the original. When I try to remember scenes from it, I
can easily remember them as frames from a Tintin comic. So it must have been
doing something right. A loss on pedant points: from the cars and the
newspapers and the general style it is obviously set in the 30s or
40s. Or possibly early 50s; I am bad with placing cars in their
proper time period. Anyhow, before the decolonialisation of Africa.
But there were at least two brief glimpses of globes showing Africa
with post-colonial political boundaries. This bugged me.
Parenthetically, the post-Versailles political map of Africa with the
northwest mostly one big green splodge looks more natural to me than
the ones I have lived with all my life – Africa is too artificially
chunked into unaesthetic bits about the same size, ugly like a
political map of the United States or Australia is ugly. The old one
was better. The contiguous parts of Francophone Africa missed a
chance by not opting to be one big country, I think. That country
would have been a player. The world would care what the position of an 'Etats Unis d'Afrique' was, much more than they do for the combined
positions of all the little countries it is broken into instead.
I watched the newest X-Men movie, about
the early days of Professor X and Magneto. It had a nice clear-cut
narrative that I thought better than that of the other X-Men movies I've seen
and a five-second scene with Wolverine that was worth the price of
the download. While in Argentina Magneto orders 'una cerveza' in an
outrageous Cathtellano lithp, rather than using the Hispano-American
pronunciation. I am not sure whether this is a loss on pedant points
or a cunning win on pedant points hinting at his European background
and why the other men in the bar then start talking to him in German.
I didn't like the bit where the token black character dies,
ostensibly heroically, just another hapless man of colour ending up as
cannon fodder in whitey's schemes. I hate being ineffectual myself
and for some reason I especially hate seeing black men being
ineffectual in fiction. Maybe I am too touchy. This sort of thing
just seems to happens in movies a lot. I should see if there is a TV
tropes page for it.
In 'Kingdom of Heaven' there was also a
token black character who was killed early on. But, at least there were no
battle scenes where Orlando Bloom 'snowboarded' down a hill on a
shield. This is a lesson to Peter Jackson: it is possible to resist
the urge to do this. I was impressed with how historically accurate
the film was. Not in absolute terms: if it had been a movie set in
the Napoleonic Wars that was as historically dodgy, I would have felt the
urge as a pedant to tear it to shreds. But that far back, the bar is
so low, it was really pleasing.
I was checking on Guy de Lusignan in
Wikipedia to find out if he was as really as much of a witless
blackguard as he is made out in the movie (hint: no) when the dearth
of female characters in the movie hit me. There is Princess Sibylla
the love interest, another love interest who is only seen in
flashback and has no speaking lines, and Saladin's sister, who has
one line in Arabic. That's all. But, in real life, there were plenty
of other female characters that could have been written in: Sibylla's
half sister Isabella, who would later be Queen of Jerusalem herself;
Sibylla's mother, Agnes of Courtenay, who seems to have played a very
active role politically (though it is possible she died shortly
before the events of the movie); Maria Comnena (mother of Isabella
and later wife of the real Balian of Ibelin). They all have
interesting life stories on Wikipedia - which also tells me they have
been portrayed in various interesting ways in previous historical fiction. It
would have been easy to construct a feminine indoors Levantine world
of intrigue to contrast with the masculine outdoor French world of
whacking each other with swords. Would have been interesting. But I
guess the movies was long enough as it is. Oh, and Sibylla didn't
just have the son who ruled as Baldwin V: she had two daughters by
Guy de Lusignan, Alice and Maria, who don't appear in the film.
Hmm. So it seems one effect of being sick may be to make me more sensitive to the treatment of women and minorities in fiction. Interesting.
One more thing I have watched is my DVD
of the first season of 'Ijon Tichy: Raumpilot'. I am used to every
DVD I own having a dozen subtitles in all sorts of languages- if I
ever want to watch Winnie-ther-Pooh with Icelandic subtitles, or
Hebrew, then I can – so I just assumed that this TV series I got on
ebay from Germany would have English subtitles. Nope. No subtitles at
all- not even German ones, which would help my really lame language
skills along. Most of it just washes over me. Once in a while I get a
complete sentence. Sometimes it is even funny, and then I laugh.
Hurrah! It may be just as well since maybe if I understood it better
I would chew my own wrists at the liberties the adaptation has taken
with the original. For example, they have given Tichy a holographic
companion. But she is a really cute chicky-babe, so that is alright.
The style is interesting. As the
original stories make no attempt to be real science fiction, the sets
make no attempt to be real science fiction sets. The spaceship is
transparently a tiny flat, with most of the action taking place in
the kitchen. The aliens are transparently people with wigs and
foam-rubber snouts. The planets are obviously made of aluminium foil.
But, the holographic companion is fit into this obviously faux world
with picture perfect CGI artistry. It is a style I did not take to at
once, but it is growing on me.
3 comments:
Hey, this is why anonymous people aren't commenting on this blog - blogger has defaulted it to a stupid 'prove you're not a robot' mode. I *want* to hear from robots. Some of my best friends (and most of my Twitter followers) are robots. I'm sure my twisted alter ego does too. Have to get in and fix this.
Ah good. I seem to recall on at least one occasion that my attempts to shepherd a comment through the stupid spam protection resulted in losing the comment and my giving up in sad disgust (side note - I meant to mention it to you and then didn't).
Just quickly because it's late and I still am sick:
- Haven't seen Tintin but I suspect the production may have been moved somewhat by the backlash in recent years against perceptions of the source material's pro-colonialism and (usually overt) racism. Hedge-betting will have gone on, I'd wager.
- I liked XFC for the most part, but the finale was a bit of a mess and there were too many characters. And the non-white characters were mostly ill-served by the script, for no good reason. And it would have been better as two hours of Michael Fassbender in a leather jacket slaughtering Nazis, if you ask me.
(Don't look at the TV Tropes entry regarding token black characters. It will make you cry).
- I liked Kingdom of Heaven way more than I expected to. It seemed to take the history more seriously than most of its ilk.
- I have no idea what that Raumpilot thing is. YouTube did not help. But I am a great admirer of shitty special effects. In this sense it was greatly endearing.
Post a Comment